
The idea that fame corrupts talent depresses me to no end. How did Billy Joel, Elton John, Queen, and the Beatles write thousands of songs as famous musicians and not lose the spark because it went to their head? I had a conversation similar to this with my friends from Brooklyn recently, and they concurred, “what happened to that band?” “They got famous.”
I’m listening to Say Anything’s new record and for whatever reason, I’m wasting my own time by reading the singer’s breakdown of every song on Alternativepress.com simultaneously. Not to mention other numerous lyrical nauseations throughout the record’s duration, there’s a song “Crush’d” about his future wife Sherri Dupree. He explains that it
“Distills my feelings so accurately about when Sherri and I first started talking that it means a lot to her too. It meant as much to me that she loved it and it I wanted her to love it as much as any other person that heard it… If no one ever heard it and it was a song that I just wrote for Sherri, I would be happy because it would let her know things that I can only express in a song.”
Does she dote? Fall head over heals over flattering lines like, “you’re no witch, you’re no wench. You’re like Bjork with better fashion sense.” or “Possibility, that I’m your guy. Though I suffer from dyslexia, mild man-orexia, and my hair cannot commit to one popular genre of music.” The depth, and sincere idolatry conveyed by such prose would make even the hardest of hearts melt. Do these people even reflect on the scribbles on the notebook page before they record it? I can’t get behind something that sounds like it should be signed “Do you like me? Circle Yes, or No” at the bottom. They will never release another record like “Is a Real Boy…” and that sucks. Perhaps this is why Against Me! and Greenday catch so much shit for “selling out.” It’s hard to believe every word of a record, to get them tattooed on your skin, to name your band after song titles or albums, to defend them on message-boards, and have them literally betray you by mediocrity. Saves The Day, Weezer, Against Me!, and a host of other flag-bearers of disappointment, pull out your old releases and listen to them.
Take the Descendents for example. Milo was off achieving All through Bio-Chemistry between 1987 and 1995. The record they wrote before his departure was alright, but when he got back they wrote their most recognizable record, “Everything Sucks.” They were already legendary (“Milo Goes To College” was an essential punk album, Bill Stevenson, former drummer of Black Flag, was recording every punk band that mattered, and All was releasing acclaimed albums), and wrote an album that almost no one can argue with. Not to mention, “Cool To Be You” being released in 2004, which is arguably their catchiest, and most focused effort ever put forth. Most bands can’t claim more than two undeniably awesome full lengths, especially when your career spans 1979-2004. The only logical thing I can associate it with, is the fact that The Descendents was never their meal ticket. They always had other things on the side (Bio-Chemistry, The Blasting Room, All, Only Crime, etc.), and were never fully able to let fame consume their talent.
In the words of Chris Conley, “Get that burn back, scorch your stomach, bleed that passion lost. Don’t forget what picked you up, don’t forget to think this time.” And answer this question before you release something, “Will people care about this decades from now?”